Go to the first, previous, next, last section, table of contents.

# Numerical Integration

This chapter describes routines for performing numerical integration (quadrature) of a function in one dimension. There are routines for adaptive and non-adaptive integration of general functions, with specialised routines for specific cases. These include integration over infinite and semi-infinite ranges, singular integrals, including logarithmic singularities, computation of Cauchy principal values and oscillatory integrals. The library reimplements the algorithms used in QUADPACK, a numerical integration package written by Piessens, de Doncker-Kapenga, Ueberhuber and Kahaner. Fortran code for QUADPACK is available on Netlib. Also included are non-adaptive, fixed-order Gauss-Legendre integration routines with high precision coefficients by Pavel Holoborodko.

The functions described in this chapter are declared in the header file gsl_integration.h'.

## Introduction

Each algorithm computes an approximation to a definite integral of the form,

I = \int_a^b f(x) w(x) dx


where w(x) is a weight function (for general integrands w(x)=1). The user provides absolute and relative error bounds (epsabs, epsrel) which specify the following accuracy requirement,

|RESULT - I|  <= max(epsabs, epsrel |I|)


where RESULT is the numerical approximation obtained by the algorithm. The algorithms attempt to estimate the absolute error ABSERR = |RESULT - I| in such a way that the following inequality holds,

|RESULT - I| <= ABSERR <= max(epsabs, epsrel |I|)


In short, the routines return the first approximation which has an absolute error smaller than epsabs or a relative error smaller than epsrel.

Note that this is an either-or constraint, not simultaneous. To compute to a specified absolute error, set epsrel to zero. To compute to a specified relative error, set epsabs to zero. The routines will fail to converge if the error bounds are too stringent, but always return the best approximation obtained up to that stage.

The algorithms in QUADPACK use a naming convention based on the following letters,

Q - quadrature routine

N - non-adaptive integrator
A - adaptive integrator

G - general integrand (user-defined)
W - weight function with integrand

S - singularities can be more readily integrated
P - points of special difficulty can be supplied
I - infinite range of integration
O - oscillatory weight function, cos or sin
F - Fourier integral
C - Cauchy principal value


The algorithms are built on pairs of quadrature rules, a higher order rule and a lower order rule. The higher order rule is used to compute the best approximation to an integral over a small range. The difference between the results of the higher order rule and the lower order rule gives an estimate of the error in the approximation.

### Integrands without weight functions

The algorithms for general functions (without a weight function) are based on Gauss-Kronrod rules.

A Gauss-Kronrod rule begins with a classical Gaussian quadrature rule of order m. This is extended with additional points between each of the abscissae to give a higher order Kronrod rule of order 2m+1. The Kronrod rule is efficient because it reuses existing function evaluations from the Gaussian rule.

The higher order Kronrod rule is used as the best approximation to the integral, and the difference between the two rules is used as an estimate of the error in the approximation.

### Integrands with weight functions

For integrands with weight functions the algorithms use Clenshaw-Curtis quadrature rules.

A Clenshaw-Curtis rule begins with an n-th order Chebyshev polynomial approximation to the integrand. This polynomial can be integrated exactly to give an approximation to the integral of the original function. The Chebyshev expansion can be extended to higher orders to improve the approximation and provide an estimate of the error.

### Integrands with singular weight functions

The presence of singularities (or other behavior) in the integrand can cause slow convergence in the Chebyshev approximation. The modified Clenshaw-Curtis rules used in QUADPACK separate out several common weight functions which cause slow convergence.

These weight functions are integrated analytically against the Chebyshev polynomials to precompute modified Chebyshev moments. Combining the moments with the Chebyshev approximation to the function gives the desired integral. The use of analytic integration for the singular part of the function allows exact cancellations and substantially improves the overall convergence behavior of the integration.

## QNG non-adaptive Gauss-Kronrod integration

The QNG algorithm is a non-adaptive procedure which uses fixed Gauss-Kronrod-Patterson abscissae to sample the integrand at a maximum of 87 points. It is provided for fast integration of smooth functions.

Function: int gsl_integration_qng (const gsl_function * f, double a, double b, double epsabs, double epsrel, double * result, double * abserr, size_t * neval)

This function applies the Gauss-Kronrod 10-point, 21-point, 43-point and 87-point integration rules in succession until an estimate of the integral of f over (a,b) is achieved within the desired absolute and relative error limits, epsabs and epsrel. The function returns the final approximation, result, an estimate of the absolute error, abserr and the number of function evaluations used, neval. The Gauss-Kronrod rules are designed in such a way that each rule uses all the results of its predecessors, in order to minimize the total number of function evaluations.

## QAG adaptive integration

The QAG algorithm is a simple adaptive integration procedure. The integration region is divided into subintervals, and on each iteration the subinterval with the largest estimated error is bisected. This reduces the overall error rapidly, as the subintervals become concentrated around local difficulties in the integrand. These subintervals are managed by a gsl_integration_workspace struct, which handles the memory for the subinterval ranges, results and error estimates.

Function: gsl_integration_workspace * gsl_integration_workspace_alloc (size_t n)
This function allocates a workspace sufficient to hold n double precision intervals, their integration results and error estimates. One workspace may be used multiple times as all necessary reinitialization is performed automatically by the integration routines.

Function: void gsl_integration_workspace_free (gsl_integration_workspace * w)
This function frees the memory associated with the workspace w.

Function: int gsl_integration_qag (const gsl_function * f, double a, double b, double epsabs, double epsrel, size_t limit, int key, gsl_integration_workspace * workspace, double * result, double * abserr)

This function applies an integration rule adaptively until an estimate of the integral of f over (a,b) is achieved within the desired absolute and relative error limits, epsabs and epsrel. The function returns the final approximation, result, and an estimate of the absolute error, abserr. The integration rule is determined by the value of key, which should be chosen from the following symbolic names,

GSL_INTEG_GAUSS15  (key = 1)
GSL_INTEG_GAUSS21  (key = 2)
GSL_INTEG_GAUSS31  (key = 3)
GSL_INTEG_GAUSS41  (key = 4)
GSL_INTEG_GAUSS51  (key = 5)
GSL_INTEG_GAUSS61  (key = 6)


corresponding to the 15, 21, 31, 41, 51 and 61 point Gauss-Kronrod rules. The higher-order rules give better accuracy for smooth functions, while lower-order rules save time when the function contains local difficulties, such as discontinuities.

On each iteration the adaptive integration strategy bisects the interval with the largest error estimate. The subintervals and their results are stored in the memory provided by workspace. The maximum number of subintervals is given by limit, which may not exceed the allocated size of the workspace.

## QAGS adaptive integration with singularities

The presence of an integrable singularity in the integration region causes an adaptive routine to concentrate new subintervals around the singularity. As the subintervals decrease in size the successive approximations to the integral converge in a limiting fashion. This approach to the limit can be accelerated using an extrapolation procedure. The QAGS algorithm combines adaptive bisection with the Wynn epsilon-algorithm to speed up the integration of many types of integrable singularities.

Function: int gsl_integration_qags (const gsl_function * f, double a, double b, double epsabs, double epsrel, size_t limit, gsl_integration_workspace * workspace, double * result, double * abserr)

This function applies the Gauss-Kronrod 21-point integration rule adaptively until an estimate of the integral of f over (a,b) is achieved within the desired absolute and relative error limits, epsabs and epsrel. The results are extrapolated using the epsilon-algorithm, which accelerates the convergence of the integral in the presence of discontinuities and integrable singularities. The function returns the final approximation from the extrapolation, result, and an estimate of the absolute error, abserr. The subintervals and their results are stored in the memory provided by workspace. The maximum number of subintervals is given by limit, which may not exceed the allocated size of the workspace.

## QAGP adaptive integration with known singular points

Function: int gsl_integration_qagp (const gsl_function * f, double * pts, size_t npts, double epsabs, double epsrel, size_t limit, gsl_integration_workspace * workspace, double * result, double * abserr)

This function applies the adaptive integration algorithm QAGS taking account of the user-supplied locations of singular points. The array pts of length npts should contain the endpoints of the integration ranges defined by the integration region and locations of the singularities. For example, to integrate over the region (a,b) with break-points at x_1, x_2, x_3 (where a < x_1 < x_2 < x_3 < b) the following pts array should be used

pts[0] = a
pts[1] = x_1
pts[2] = x_2
pts[3] = x_3
pts[4] = b


with npts = 5.

If you know the locations of the singular points in the integration region then this routine will be faster than QAGS.

## QAGI adaptive integration on infinite intervals

Function: int gsl_integration_qagi (gsl_function * f, double epsabs, double epsrel, size_t limit, gsl_integration_workspace * workspace, double * result, double * abserr)

This function computes the integral of the function f over the infinite interval (-\infty,+\infty). The integral is mapped onto the semi-open interval (0,1] using the transformation x = (1-t)/t,

\int_{-\infty}^{+\infty} dx f(x) =
\int_0^1 dt (f((1-t)/t) + f((-1+t)/t))/t^2.


It is then integrated using the QAGS algorithm. The normal 21-point Gauss-Kronrod rule of QAGS is replaced by a 15-point rule, because the transformation can generate an integrable singularity at the origin. In this case a lower-order rule is more efficient.

Function: int gsl_integration_qagiu (gsl_function * f, double a, double epsabs, double epsrel, size_t limit, gsl_integration_workspace * workspace, double * result, double * abserr)

This function computes the integral of the function f over the semi-infinite interval (a,+\infty). The integral is mapped onto the semi-open interval (0,1] using the transformation x = a + (1-t)/t,

\int_{a}^{+\infty} dx f(x) =
\int_0^1 dt f(a + (1-t)/t)/t^2


and then integrated using the QAGS algorithm.

Function: int gsl_integration_qagil (gsl_function * f, double b, double epsabs, double epsrel, size_t limit, gsl_integration_workspace * workspace, double * result, double * abserr)
This function computes the integral of the function f over the semi-infinite interval (-\infty,b). The integral is mapped onto the semi-open interval (0,1] using the transformation x = b - (1-t)/t,

\int_{-\infty}^{b} dx f(x) =
\int_0^1 dt f(b - (1-t)/t)/t^2


and then integrated using the QAGS algorithm.

## QAWC adaptive integration for Cauchy principal values

Function: int gsl_integration_qawc (gsl_function * f, double a, double b, double c, double epsabs, double epsrel, size_t limit, gsl_integration_workspace * workspace, double * result, double * abserr)

This function computes the Cauchy principal value of the integral of f over (a,b), with a singularity at c,

I = \int_a^b dx f(x) / (x - c)


The adaptive bisection algorithm of QAG is used, with modifications to ensure that subdivisions do not occur at the singular point x = c. When a subinterval contains the point x = c or is close to it then a special 25-point modified Clenshaw-Curtis rule is used to control the singularity. Further away from the singularity the algorithm uses an ordinary 15-point Gauss-Kronrod integration rule.

## QAWS adaptive integration for singular functions

The QAWS algorithm is designed for integrands with algebraic-logarithmic singularities at the end-points of an integration region. In order to work efficiently the algorithm requires a precomputed table of Chebyshev moments.

Function: gsl_integration_qaws_table * gsl_integration_qaws_table_alloc (double alpha, double beta, int mu, int nu)
This function allocates space for a gsl_integration_qaws_table struct describing a singular weight function W(x) with the parameters (\alpha, \beta, \mu, \nu),

W(x) = (x-a)^alpha (b-x)^beta log^mu (x-a) log^nu (b-x)


where \alpha > -1, \beta > -1, and \mu = 0, 1, \nu = 0, 1. The weight function can take four different forms depending on the values of \mu and \nu,

W(x) = (x-a)^alpha (b-x)^beta                   (mu = 0, nu = 0)
W(x) = (x-a)^alpha (b-x)^beta log(x-a)          (mu = 1, nu = 0)
W(x) = (x-a)^alpha (b-x)^beta log(b-x)          (mu = 0, nu = 1)
W(x) = (x-a)^alpha (b-x)^beta log(x-a) log(b-x) (mu = 1, nu = 1)


The singular points (a,b) do not have to be specified until the integral is computed, where they are the endpoints of the integration range.

The function returns a pointer to the newly allocated table gsl_integration_qaws_table if no errors were detected, and 0 in the case of error.

Function: int gsl_integration_qaws_table_set (gsl_integration_qaws_table * t, double alpha, double beta, int mu, int nu)
This function modifies the parameters (\alpha, \beta, \mu, \nu) of an existing gsl_integration_qaws_table struct t.

Function: void gsl_integration_qaws_table_free (gsl_integration_qaws_table * t)
This function frees all the memory associated with the gsl_integration_qaws_table struct t.

Function: int gsl_integration_qaws (gsl_function * f, const double a, const double b, gsl_integration_qaws_table * t, const double epsabs, const double epsrel, const size_t limit, gsl_integration_workspace * workspace, double * result, double * abserr)

This function computes the integral of the function f(x) over the interval (a,b) with the singular weight function (x-a)^\alpha (b-x)^\beta \log^\mu (x-a) \log^\nu (b-x). The parameters of the weight function (\alpha, \beta, \mu, \nu) are taken from the table t. The integral is,

I = \int_a^b dx f(x) (x-a)^alpha (b-x)^beta log^mu (x-a) log^nu (b-x).


The adaptive bisection algorithm of QAG is used. When a subinterval contains one of the endpoints then a special 25-point modified Clenshaw-Curtis rule is used to control the singularities. For subintervals which do not include the endpoints an ordinary 15-point Gauss-Kronrod integration rule is used.

## QAWO adaptive integration for oscillatory functions

The QAWO algorithm is designed for integrands with an oscillatory factor, \sin(\omega x) or \cos(\omega x). In order to work efficiently the algorithm requires a table of Chebyshev moments which must be pre-computed with calls to the functions below.

Function: gsl_integration_qawo_table * gsl_integration_qawo_table_alloc (double omega, double L, enum gsl_integration_qawo_enum sine, size_t n)
This function allocates space for a gsl_integration_qawo_table struct and its associated workspace describing a sine or cosine weight function W(x) with the parameters (\omega, L),

W(x) = sin(omega x)
W(x) = cos(omega x)


The parameter L must be the length of the interval over which the function will be integrated L = b - a. The choice of sine or cosine is made with the parameter sine which should be chosen from one of the two following symbolic values:

GSL_INTEG_COSINE
GSL_INTEG_SINE


The gsl_integration_qawo_table is a table of the trigonometric coefficients required in the integration process. The parameter n determines the number of levels of coefficients that are computed. Each level corresponds to one bisection of the interval L, so that n levels are sufficient for subintervals down to the length L/2^n. The integration routine gsl_integration_qawo returns the error GSL_ETABLE if the number of levels is insufficient for the requested accuracy.

Function: int gsl_integration_qawo_table_set (gsl_integration_qawo_table * t, double omega, double L, enum gsl_integration_qawo_enum sine)
This function changes the parameters omega, L and sine of the existing workspace t.

Function: int gsl_integration_qawo_table_set_length (gsl_integration_qawo_table * t, double L)
This function allows the length parameter L of the workspace t to be changed.

Function: void gsl_integration_qawo_table_free (gsl_integration_qawo_table * t)
This function frees all the memory associated with the workspace t.

Function: int gsl_integration_qawo (gsl_function * f, const double a, const double epsabs, const double epsrel, const size_t limit, gsl_integration_workspace * workspace, gsl_integration_qawo_table * wf, double * result, double * abserr)

This function uses an adaptive algorithm to compute the integral of f over (a,b) with the weight function \sin(\omega x) or \cos(\omega x) defined by the table wf,

I = \int_a^b dx f(x) sin(omega x)
I = \int_a^b dx f(x) cos(omega x)


The results are extrapolated using the epsilon-algorithm to accelerate the convergence of the integral. The function returns the final approximation from the extrapolation, result, and an estimate of the absolute error, abserr. The subintervals and their results are stored in the memory provided by workspace. The maximum number of subintervals is given by limit, which may not exceed the allocated size of the workspace.

Those subintervals with "large" widths d where d\omega > 4 are computed using a 25-point Clenshaw-Curtis integration rule, which handles the oscillatory behavior. Subintervals with a "small" widths where d\omega < 4 are computed using a 15-point Gauss-Kronrod integration.

## QAWF adaptive integration for Fourier integrals

Function: int gsl_integration_qawf (gsl_function * f, const double a, const double epsabs, const size_t limit, gsl_integration_workspace * workspace, gsl_integration_workspace * cycle_workspace, gsl_integration_qawo_table * wf, double * result, double * abserr)

This function attempts to compute a Fourier integral of the function f over the semi-infinite interval [a,+\infty).

I = \int_a^{+\infty} dx f(x) sin(omega x)
I = \int_a^{+\infty} dx f(x) cos(omega x)


The parameter \omega and choice of \sin or \cos is taken from the table wf (the length L can take any value, since it is overridden by this function to a value appropriate for the Fourier integration). The integral is computed using the QAWO algorithm over each of the subintervals,

C_1 = [a, a + c]
C_2 = [a + c, a + 2 c]
... = ...
C_k = [a + (k-1) c, a + k c]


where c = (2 floor(|\omega|) + 1) \pi/|\omega|. The width c is chosen to cover an odd number of periods so that the contributions from the intervals alternate in sign and are monotonically decreasing when f is positive and monotonically decreasing. The sum of this sequence of contributions is accelerated using the epsilon-algorithm.

This function works to an overall absolute tolerance of abserr. The following strategy is used: on each interval C_k the algorithm tries to achieve the tolerance

TOL_k = u_k abserr


where u_k = (1 - p)p^{k-1} and p = 9/10. The sum of the geometric series of contributions from each interval gives an overall tolerance of abserr.

If the integration of a subinterval leads to difficulties then the accuracy requirement for subsequent intervals is relaxed,

TOL_k = u_k max(abserr, max_{i<k}{E_i})


where E_k is the estimated error on the interval C_k.

The subintervals and their results are stored in the memory provided by workspace. The maximum number of subintervals is given by limit, which may not exceed the allocated size of the workspace. The integration over each subinterval uses the memory provided by cycle_workspace as workspace for the QAWO algorithm.

## CQUAD doubly-adaptive integration

CQUAD is a new doubly-adaptive general-purpose quadrature routine which can handle most types of singularities, non-numerical function values such as Inf or NaN, as well as some divergent integrals. It generally requires more function evaluations than the integration routines in QUADPACK, yet fails less often for difficult integrands.

The underlying algorithm uses a doubly-adaptive scheme in which Clenshaw-Curtis quadrature rules of increasing degree are used to compute the integral in each interval. The L_2-norm of the difference between the underlying interpolatory polynomials of two successive rules is used as an error estimate. The interval is subdivided if the difference between two successive rules is too large or a rule of maximum degree has been reached.

Function: gsl_integration_cquad_workspace * gsl_integration_cquad_workspace_alloc (size_t n)
This function allocates a workspace sufficient to hold the data for n intervals. The number n is not the maximum number of intervals that will be evaluated. If the workspace is full, intervals with smaller error estimates will be discarded. A minimum of 3 intervals is required and for most functions, a workspace of size 100 is sufficient.

Function: void gsl_integration_cquad_workspace_free (gsl_integration_cquad_workspace * w)
This function frees the memory associated with the workspace w.

Function: int gsl_integration_cquad (const gsl_function * f, double a, double b, double epsabs, double epsrel, gsl_integration_cquad_workspace * workspace, double * result, double * abserr, size_t * nevals)
This function computes the integral of f over (a,b) within the desired absolute and relative error limits, epsabs and epsrel using the CQUAD algorithm. The function returns the final approximation, result, an estimate of the absolute error, abserr, and the number of function evaluations required, nevals.

The CQUAD algorithm divides the integration region into subintervals, and in each iteration, the subinterval with the largest estimated error is processed. The algorithm uses Clenshaw-Curits quadrature rules of degree 4, 8, 16 and 32 over 5, 9, 17 and 33 nodes respectively. Each interval is initialized with the lowest-degree rule. When an interval is processed, the next-higher degree rule is evaluated and an error estimate is computed based on the L_2-norm of the difference between the underlying interpolating polynomials of both rules. If the highest-degree rule has already been used, or the interpolatory polynomials differ significantly, the interval is bisected.

The subintervals and their results are stored in the memory provided by workspace. If the error estimate or the number of function evaluations is not needed, the pointers abserr and nevals can be set to NULL.

## Gauss-Legendre integration

The fixed-order Gauss-Legendre integration routines are provided for fast integration of smooth functions with known polynomial order. The n-point Gauss-Legendre rule is exact for polynomials of order 2*n-1 or less. For example, these rules are useful when integrating basis functions to form mass matrices for the Galerkin method. Unlike other numerical integration routines within the library, these routines do not accept absolute or relative error bounds.

Function: gsl_integration_glfixed_table * gsl_integration_glfixed_table_alloc (size_t n)
This function determines the Gauss-Legendre abscissae and weights necessary for an n-point fixed order integration scheme. If possible, high precision precomputed coefficients are used. If precomputed weights are not available, lower precision coefficients are computed on the fly.

Function: double gsl_integration_glfixed ({const gsl_function *} f, double a, double b, {const gsl_integration_glfixed_table *} t)
This function applies the Gauss-Legendre integration rule contained in table t and returns the result.

Function: int gsl_integration_glfixed_point (double a, double b, size_t i, {double *} xi, {double *} wi, {const gsl_integration_glfixed_table *} t)
For i in [0, ..., t->n - 1], this function obtains the i-th Gauss-Legendre point xi and weight wi on the interval [a,b]. The points and weights are ordered by increasing point value. A function f may be integrated on [a,b] by summing wi * f(xi) over i.

Function: void gsl_integration_glfixed_table_free ({gsl_integration_glfixed_table *} t)
This function frees the memory associated with the table t.

## Error codes

In addition to the standard error codes for invalid arguments the functions can return the following values,

GSL_EMAXITER
the maximum number of subdivisions was exceeded.
GSL_EROUND
cannot reach tolerance because of roundoff error, or roundoff error was detected in the extrapolation table.
GSL_ESING
a non-integrable singularity or other bad integrand behavior was found in the integration interval.
GSL_EDIVERGE
the integral is divergent, or too slowly convergent to be integrated numerically.

## Examples

The integrator QAGS will handle a large class of definite integrals. For example, consider the following integral, which has an algebraic-logarithmic singularity at the origin,

\int_0^1 x^{-1/2} log(x) dx = -4


The program below computes this integral to a relative accuracy bound of 1e-7.

#include <stdio.h>
#include <math.h>
#include <gsl/gsl_integration.h>

double f (double x, void * params) {
double alpha = *(double *) params;
double f = log(alpha*x) / sqrt(x);
return f;
}

int
main (void)
{
gsl_integration_workspace * w
= gsl_integration_workspace_alloc (1000);

double result, error;
double expected = -4.0;
double alpha = 1.0;

gsl_function F;
F.function = &f;
F.params = &alpha;

gsl_integration_qags (&F, 0, 1, 0, 1e-7, 1000,
w, &result, &error);

printf ("result          = % .18f\n", result);
printf ("exact result    = % .18f\n", expected);
printf ("estimated error = % .18f\n", error);
printf ("actual error    = % .18f\n", result - expected);
printf ("intervals =  %d\n", w->size);

gsl_integration_workspace_free (w);

return 0;
}


The results below show that the desired accuracy is achieved after 8 subdivisions.

\$ ./a.out
result          = -3.999999999999973799
exact result    = -4.000000000000000000
estimated error =  0.000000000000246025
actual error    =  0.000000000000026201
intervals =  8


In fact, the extrapolation procedure used by QAGS` produces an accuracy of almost twice as many digits. The error estimate returned by the extrapolation procedure is larger than the actual error, giving a margin of safety of one order of magnitude.

## References and Further Reading

The following book is the definitive reference for QUADPACK, and was written by the original authors. It provides descriptions of the algorithms, program listings, test programs and examples. It also includes useful advice on numerical integration and many references to the numerical integration literature used in developing QUADPACK.

• R. Piessens, E. de Doncker-Kapenga, C.W. Ueberhuber, D.K. Kahaner. QUADPACK A subroutine package for automatic integration Springer Verlag, 1983.

The CQUAD integration algorithm is described in the following paper:

• P. Gonnet, "Increasing the Reliability of Adaptive Quadrature Using Explicit Interpolants", ACM Transactions on Mathematical Software, Volume 37 (2010), Issue 3, Article 26.

Go to the first, previous, next, last section, table of contents.